Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

Plant water balance: tailings water, decant return, evaporation and make-up water

A process plant water balance: water in slurry, water retained in tailings, pond evaporation, decant return and raw water make-up, with worked examples.

· 5 minute read · By

A processing plant uses large volumes of water to transport ore as slurry, and most of that water leaves the plant with the tailings. At the tailings storage facility the solids settle, and part of the water collects on the surface, from which it can be pumped back to the plant. The remainder is lost to evaporation and seepage, or is retained in the pores of the settled tailings.

A water balance accounts for every cubic metre. It establishes the plant's fresh water requirement, identifies the losses, and shows which changes would save the most water. In the arid regions of Australia, where water is scarce and licensed, it is one of the most important plant calculations.

This article builds a simple plant and tailings water balance for a 300 t/h plant and then assesses the effect of thickening the tailings. Site balances add rainfall, runoff, borefield water quality and seasonal evaporation, but are built from the same components.

Plant and tailings water balanceRaw water and water in ore enter the plant. Water leaves with the tailings to the storage facility, where it is lost to evaporation, seepage and the pores of the tailings, and the rest returns as decant water.Raw watermake-upWater in oremoistureProcesswater tankProcessingplantTailings storagefacilityEvaporation, seepage,water held in tailingstailings slurrydecant returnwater in = water out + change in storage, for every box
A simple site water balance. Real balances add rainfall and runoff, thickener overflow, gland water, and separate potable and process water.

Water in slurry

water in−water out=change in storageWslurry=Ms×1−CwCw

where

Wslurry
water carried by a slurry stream (m³/h, taking water as 1 t/m³)
Ms
dry solids rate (t/h)
Cw
solids concentration by mass (fraction)

The water carried by a slurry follows from its solids concentration. Worked example: 300 t/h of tailings solids at 50% solids by mass carries 300 × 0.50 ÷ 0.50 = 300 m³/h of water, and at 60% solids it would carry 300 × 0.40 ÷ 0.60 = 200 m³/h. The pulp density calculator converts between slurry density and percent solids.

Losses at the tailings storage facility

Wretained=Ms×(1ρd−1Gs)Wevaporation=kp×Epan×Apond

where

Wretained
water locked in the pores of settled, saturated tailings (m³/h)
ρd
settled dry density of the tailings (t/m³)
Gs
specific gravity of the tailings solids
kp
pan coefficient converting evaporation pan readings to open water, often taken as about 0.7 but best set from site data
Epan
pan evaporation (m/d)
Apond
area of free water and wet beach (m²)

Water retained in the tailings: once the tailings settle to a dry density of 1.4 t/m³ with a solids SG of 2.8, the pores occupy 1 ÷ 1.4 − 1 ÷ 2.8 = 0.357 m³ per tonne of solids. At 300 t/h, 107 m³/h is retained in the pores and is not recoverable.

Evaporation: with 30 ha of free water and wet beach, pan evaporation of 8 mm/d and a pan coefficient of 0.7, the pond loses 0.7 × 0.008 × 300,000 = 1,680 m³/d, or 70 m³/h. Pan evaporation is highly seasonal, so a monthly balance is preferable to an annual average for sizing the water supply.

Seepage is estimated from the facility design and monitoring bores, and is taken as 10 m³/h here.

The decant return is the remainder: 300 − 107 − 70 − 10 = 113 m³/h, about 38% of the water sent to the facility.

Where 300 m³/h of tailings water goes107 cubic metres per hour stays in the pores of the tailings, 70 evaporates, 10 seeps, and 113 comes back as decant water.Locked in tailings poresLocked in tailings pores: 107107Evaporation from the pondEvaporation from the pond: 7070SeepageSeepage: 1010Returned as decantReturned as decant: 113113Water (m³/h)
In this example only about 38% of the water sent to the tailings storage facility comes back. The water locked in the tailings is lost however the facility is run. Illustrative figures.

Raw water make-up

make-up water=water leaving the plant−water in ore−water returned

where

water leaving the plant
water in tailings, concentrates and losses such as evaporation from tanks
water returned
decant return from the storage facility plus thickener overflow and other recycled water

The ore brings some water with it: 300 t/h of dry ore at 3% moisture carries 9 m³/h. With 300 m³/h leaving in the tailings and 113 m³/h returning, the plant requires 300 − 9 − 113 = 178 m³/h of raw water, or about 0.59 m³ per tonne of ore. Minor flows, such as gland seal water, reagent make-up and dust suppression, should be added for a complete balance.

Effect of tailings thickening

In this case a tailings thickener raises the solids concentration to 60% before the slurry leaves the plant. The thickener overflow, 100 m³/h, returns directly to the process water tank, and the smaller volume of water sent to the facility allows the decant pond to contract to about 15 ha.

Item (m³/h)Base case, 50% solidsThickened, 60% solids
Water sent to the storage facility300200
Locked in tailings pores107107
Pond evaporation7035
Seepage1010
Decant return11348
Thickener overflow return0100
Raw water make-up178143

The saving of 35 m³/h comes almost entirely from reduced evaporation. The water retained in the tailings pores does not change, because it depends on the settled density of the tailings rather than on the density at which they were pumped. Filtered (dry-stacked) tailings also reduce that loss, at a higher cost.

Maintaining the water balance

The major flows should be measured: raw water, decant return, and tailings flow and density. Flowmeters on slurry and return lines drift and should be checked against tank level changes. The balance should be closed monthly, since an unexplained difference indicates a faulty meter, unrecorded use or a leak.

The settled density should be measured, by sampling the beach or from survey volumes and tonnes placed, because it determines the largest loss. The balance should also cover the wet season, as a balance based only on dry months can miss the risk of excess water in the facility after heavy rain.

Glossary

Water balance
An account of all water entering and leaving a plant or site, including changes in storage.
Tailings storage facility (TSF)
The engineered structure that stores tailings solids and the water released from them.
Decant return
Water pumped back from the pond on top of the tailings to the plant.
Settled dry density
Mass of tailings solids per cubic metre of settled tailings.
Pan evaporation
Evaporation measured from a standard open pan; converted to open water with a pan coefficient.
Seepage
Water that leaves the storage facility through its base or walls.
Make-up water
Fresh or raw water added to the plant to replace water lost.
Thickener overflow
Clear water from the top of a thickener, usually returned to the process water tank.

Frequently asked questions

How much water does a gold plant use?

It depends mainly on the water leaving with the tailings and the proportion returned. In the example, raw water use is about 0.6 m³ per tonne; thickening reduced it to about 0.5 m³ per tonne.

Why can't all the tailings water be recovered?

Part of it is retained in the pores of the settled tailings, and part evaporates from the pond. Only the free water on the surface can be decanted.

What is a pan coefficient?

A factor that converts evaporation from a standard pan to evaporation from a large water surface. It is often taken as about 0.7, but site data are preferable.

How can raw water use be reduced?

By thickening the tailings, keeping the decant pond small and returning water promptly, reducing spillage and leaks, and considering filtered tailings where water is very scarce.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. Australian National Committee on Large Dams (ANCOLD) (2019). Guidelines on Tailings Dams: Planning, Design, Construction, Operation and Closure. Revision 1.
  2. Minerals Council of Australia (2014). Water Accounting Framework for the Minerals Industry, User Guide, version 1.3.
  3. Wills, B.A. and Finch, J.A. (2016). Wills' Mineral Processing Technology, 8th edition. Butterworth-Heinemann. Chapter 15, Dewatering.

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.