Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

Gravity concentration: the concentration criterion, settling velocity and recovery calculations

The conditions for effective gravity separation: the concentration criterion, Stokes' law settling, equipment selection and recovery per pass, with worked examples.

· 5 minute read · By

Gravity concentration separates minerals by differences in density. The principle is the same as in a gold pan, where light sand is washed over the rim while the heavy gold settles to the bottom. Industrial equipment applies it at scale: jigs pulse water upward through a bed, spirals carry slurry around a helical trough, shaking tables move a film of water across a riffled deck, and centrifugal concentrators spin the feed in a bowl at high speed.

Gravity separation is most effective when the valuable mineral is much denser than the gangue and the particles are not too fine. Fine particles of any mineral settle slowly and are carried by the water, so the density difference loses its effect. The calculations in this article establish whether gravity separation is feasible and how its performance is measured.

Gravity circuits recover coarse gold in most gold plants, produce tin, tungsten, chromite and mineral sands concentrates, and pre-concentrate many other ores. This article covers the two rules that determine whether gravity can work, the main equipment types, and the recovery calculations used to operate a gravity circuit. Testwork for gold is covered in gravity recoverable gold testing.

The concentration criterion

CC=ρh−ρfρl−ρf

where

ρh, ρl
densities of the heavy and light minerals
ρf
density of the fluid: 1.0 for water

For gold (SG 19.3) and quartz (2.65) in water, the criterion is (19.3 − 1) ÷ (2.65 − 1) = 11.1, a very easy separation. For spodumene (about 3.15) and quartz it is (3.15 − 1) ÷ (2.65 − 1) = 1.3, too close for water-based gravity separation.

Concentration criterion in waterGold and quartz 11.1, galena and quartz 3.9, cassiterite and quartz 3.6, chromite and serpentine 2.25, spodumene and quartz 1.3.Gold / quartzGold / quartz: 11.0911.09Galena / quartzGalena / quartz: 3.943.94Cassiterite / quartzCassiterite / quartz: 3.643.64Chromite / serpentineChromite / serpentine: 2.252.25Spodumene / quartzSpodumene / quartz: 1.301.30Concentration criterion (water)
The higher the criterion, the finer the particles that water-based gravity methods can separate. Spodumene and quartz are too close in density for water-based gravity, which is why dense media is used.

A widely quoted guide, attributed to Taggart, relates the criterion to the finest size at which gravity separation is practical:

Concentration criterionGuide
Above 2.5Relatively easy, down to about 75 µm
2.5 to 1.75Effective down to about 150 µm
1.75 to 1.5Possible down to about 1.7 mm, but difficult
1.5 to 1.25Possible down to about 6 mm, but difficult
Below 1.25Not practical in water

The table is a guide only. Particle shape, liberation and modern centrifugal equipment all shift the limits. Where the criterion is low, as for spodumene, dense media separation replaces water with a heavy suspension; see heavy liquid separation for spodumene.

Settling of fine particles: Stokes' law

v=gd2(ρs−ρf)18μ

where

v
terminal settling velocity (m/s); valid for small particles in slow, smooth flow
d
particle diameter (m)
ρs, ρf
particle and fluid densities (kg/m³)
μ
fluid viscosity (Pa·s; 0.001 for water at 20 °C)

A 50 µm gold particle settles in water at about 25 mm/s and a 50 µm quartz particle at about 2.2 mm/s. A quartz particle 166 µm across, however, settles as fast as the 50 µm gold particle, and the two behave alike in a classifier or in any equipment that relies on settling. Settling velocity falls with the square of particle size, so at 10 µm even gold settles at only 1 mm/s and is readily carried away by water currents.

Settling velocity in water against particle sizeGold settles about eleven times faster than quartz of the same size; a 50 µm gold particle settles like a 166 µm quartz particle.0255075100020406080100Particle size (µm)Settling velocity (mm/s)Gold (SG 19.3)Quartz (SG 2.65)GoldQuartz
Stokes' law settling velocities. Fine particles of any mineral settle slowly, which is why fine gravity separation needs the higher forces of centrifugal concentrators.

Centrifugal concentrators overcome this limitation by spinning the slurry at tens to hundreds of times the force of gravity, which multiplies the settling velocity by the same factor. For this reason they are the dominant equipment for gold recovery from grinding circuits.

Gravity separation equipment

EquipmentPrincipleTypical use
JigsWater pulses up and down through a bed; heavy particles sink to the bottom layerCoarse gold and alluvials, coarse tin, iron ore, coal
SpiralsSlurry flows down a helical trough; heavy particles stay near the inner edgeMineral sands, iron ore, chromite
Shaking tablesA riffled deck moves back and forth under a film of water; heavy particles move along the rifflesCleaning gravity concentrates, tin, tungsten
Centrifugal concentratorsA spinning bowl with fluidising water traps heavy particles in ringsGold from cyclone underflow or mill discharge

Recovery calculations

recovery per pass=CcFf

where

C, c
concentrate mass rate and gold grade
F, f
feed mass rate and gold grade of the stream treated

Worked example: a centrifugal concentrator treats 60 t/h of cyclone underflow at 4.0 g/t gold and produces 30 kg/h of concentrate at 2,800 g/t. Recovery per pass = (0.030 × 2,800) ÷ (60 × 4.0) = 84 ÷ 240 = 35%, from a mass pull of only 0.05%.

A recovery of 35% per pass is not the plant's gravity recovery. In a grinding circuit the underflow returns to the mill and passes through the concentrator many times, so gold not recovered on one pass has further opportunities. Gravity gold also accumulates in the circulating load, which is why the underflow grade (4.0 g/t) is higher than the plant feed grade. Overall gravity recovery is estimated with models based on GRG test results and circuit surveys, as described in the GRG article.

Coarse gold makes gravity circuit samples highly variable. Large samples should be taken, following the guidance in Gy's sampling formula, and recoveries should be checked against a gold balance across the whole plant.

Glossary

Gravity concentration
Separating minerals by density using water, motion and gravity or centrifugal force.
Concentration criterion
(Heavy mineral density − fluid density) ÷ (light mineral density − fluid density).
Stokes' law
The settling velocity of a small particle in a fluid, proportional to its size squared and its density difference.
Centrifugal concentrator
A spinning bowl that traps heavy particles under many times the force of gravity.
Mass pull
The percentage of the feed mass that reports to concentrate.
Recovery per pass
The fraction of the gold in the stream treated that one pass through the concentrator captures.
Circulating load
Material returned from the classifier to the mill, which passes through the circuit many times.

Frequently asked questions

What is the concentration criterion?

A ratio of density differences, (heavy − fluid) ÷ (light − fluid), that indicates how easy a gravity separation will be. Above 2.5 is relatively easy; below 1.25 is not practical in water.

Why can't gravity separate fine particles?

Settling velocity falls with the square of particle size, so fine particles of any mineral settle slowly and are carried by water currents. Centrifugal force assists by multiplying the settling velocity.

How is recovery per pass calculated for a gravity concentrator?

Concentrate mass rate multiplied by concentrate grade, divided by feed mass rate multiplied by feed grade, for the stream that the concentrator treats.

Can gravity separate spodumene from quartz?

Not in water: the concentration criterion is about 1.3. Dense media separation, using a heavy suspension, is used instead.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. Wills, B.A. and Finch, J.A. (2016). Wills' Mineral Processing Technology, 8th edition. Butterworth-Heinemann. Chapter 10, Gravity concentration.
  2. Burt, R.O. (1984). Gravity Concentration Technology. Elsevier.
  3. Laplante, A.R. and Clarke, J. (2006). A simple gravity-recoverable gold test. Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum.

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.