Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

Commissioning a mineral processing plant: phases, tools and checklists from construction to steady state

Processing plant commissioning: phases and certificates, Gantt chart, punch lists, checklists, RACI, ramp-up and performance tests.

· 16 minute read · By

Commissioning proceeds in a fixed sequence. The plant is first checked to confirm that it was built as designed and is safe to energise. Power and controls are then switched on and each motor run without load. The plant is next filled with water and operated as if it were processing ore. Only then is ore fed and reagents introduced, and the plant brought progressively to its design rate. Finally, a formal test demonstrates that the plant performs as specified in the contract. Each step ends with a signed certificate, so that all parties agree when an area of the plant is ready for the next step and who is responsible for it.

Commissioning tests a project's design, construction and operating readiness at the same time. Done well, the plant reaches nameplate within months and the owner receives the plant it paid for; done poorly, ramp-up can take years, or the plant may never reach design. This article sets out the phases, the tools that keep commissioning under control, a set of adaptable templates, and the measurements used in ramp-up and performance testing. The example throughout is a carbon-in-leach (CIL) gold plant designed for 300 t/h.

Commissioning phases

Commissioning phases and certificatesConstruction, mechanical completion, pre-commissioning, water commissioning, ore commissioning, ramp-up, performance test and handover, with the certificate that closes each phase.Constructionand checksPre-commissioningWatercommissioningOrecommissioningRamp-upto nameplatePerformancetest, handovermechanical completionready for commissioningready for oreperformance acceptanceEach arrow is a gate: a signed certificatethat the exit criteria of the phase are met
The commissioning sequence. Each phase ends with a signed certificate against agreed exit criteria, so nobody argues later about when a system was ready.
PhaseActivitiesLeadExit certificate
Construction completionSystems built and checked against drawings; walkdowns raise punch list items; construction tests (pressure tests, insulation resistance, alignment) done and recordedConstruction contractor, with commissioning team witnessingMechanical completion
Pre-commissioning (cold, dry)Power energised; control system, instrument loops and I/O checked; motor rotation and no-load runs; valves stroked; interlocks tested; lubrication systems flushedCommissioning team, with vendorsReady for commissioning
Water commissioning (wet)Circuits run on water: pumps, levels, flows, controls and interlocks tested under process conditions; leaks fixed; flowmeters checkedCommissioning team; operators running the plant under supervisionReady for ore (or ready for start-up)
Ore commissioning (hot)First ore fed at reduced rate; reagents introduced; each circuit brought on line in sequence; first productCommissioning team and operations togetherPractical completion (often per area)
Ramp-upThroughput, availability and recovery pushed towards design; defects and bottlenecks fixedOperations, supported by commissioning and vendorsReady for performance test
Performance test and handoverFormal test against guarantees; documentation, spares and training handed overOwner and contractor jointlyPerformance acceptance; final handover

Terminology differs between companies and contracts; some refer to pre-commissioning as "cold commissioning" and to ore commissioning as "hot commissioning". The essential requirement is that the phases, their exit criteria and the certificates are defined in writing before construction ends.

System breakdown and commissioning register

Construction is organised by area, so that everything in the grinding building is built together. Commissioning is organised by system: the SAG mill lubrication system, the cyclone feed pumps, the lime slaking system. A system is a set of equipment that can be tested and handed over as a unit, with defined boundaries such as an isolation valve or a motor control centre bucket.

Commissioning system breakdownPlant split into areas, areas into systems, systems into subsystems, subsystems into tagged equipment.CIL plant2000Crushing3000Grinding4000Leach and CIL5000Elution, gold room7000Services3100 SAG mill3200 Ball mill3300 Cyclones3110 SAG lube system: 3110-PP-001, 3110-TK-001 …
Commissioning by system. Every tag in the plant belongs to exactly one subsystem, and each subsystem is commissioned, documented and handed over as a unit.

The commissioning register lists every system and subsystem, with every equipment tag assigned to exactly one of them. For each subsystem it records the boundaries, checklists, status (construction, pre-commissioning, water, ore), open punch items and certificates. It is the master record of commissioning progress and should be established early in construction from the equipment list and the piping and instrumentation diagrams.

SystemSubsystemTagsMechanical completionPre-commissioningWaterOpen AOpen B
3100 SAG mill3110 Lube system3110-PP-001/002, 3110-TK-001, 3110-HX-001SignedCompleten/a04
3100 SAG mill3120 Mill drive3120-ML-001, 3120-MT-001SignedIn progressNot started29
3300 Cyclones3310 Cyclone feed3310-PP-001/002, 3310-CY-001SignedCompleteIn progress06

Gantt chart and critical path

A Gantt chart shows every commissioning activity as a bar against time, with the links between activities. It shows at a glance what must happen in the current week, which activities depend on which, and which delays will postpone first ore or first gold.

Commissioning Gantt chartTwenty-week commissioning schedule for a CIL plant. Critical path tasks in orange: energisation, control system, loop checks, interlocks, water commissioning, CIL, elution, performance test. Milestones: first ore in week 12, first gold in week 15.1234567891011121314151617181920WeekConstruction completion, punch walkdownsConstruction completion, punch walkdowns: weeks 1 to 4Operator training and proceduresOperator training and procedures: weeks 2 to 12HV/LV energisation and MCCsHV/LV energisation and MCCs: weeks 1 to 3PLC/SCADA and network checksPLC/SCADA and network checks: weeks 2 to 5Instrument loop and I/O checksInstrument loop and I/O checks: weeks 3 to 7Motor rotation and no-load runsMotor rotation and no-load runs: weeks 4 to 7Interlock (cause and effect) testsInterlock (cause and effect) tests: weeks 6 to 8Water systems: raw, process, fireWater systems: raw, process, fire: weeks 5 to 8Water commissioning: grinding, CILWater commissioning: grinding, CIL: weeks 8 to 10Reagents: lime, cyanide readinessReagents: lime, cyanide readiness: weeks 8 to 11Crushing circuit on oreCrushing circuit on ore: weeks 10 to 11First ore to millFirst ore to mill: week 12CIL fill, leach and adsorptionCIL fill, leach and adsorption: weeks 12 to 14Elution, electrowinning, gold roomElution, electrowinning, gold room: weeks 13 to 15First gold pourFirst gold pour: week 15Ramp-up to nameplateRamp-up to nameplate: weeks 12 to 19Performance testPerformance test: weeks 19 to 20Critical pathOther activityMilestone
A 20-week commissioning Gantt chart for a carbon-in-leach plant. Orange bars are on the critical path: any delay to them delays first gold. Blue bars have float. Diamonds are milestones. Illustrative schedule.

The chart is built and used as follows:

  1. List the activities by system, from the commissioning register, at a level a supervisor can manage: "Cyclone feed pumps: rotation, no-load run, water run", not "Commission grinding".
  2. Estimate durations from experience and vendor input, including the availability of vendor representatives.
  3. Link the activities. Most links are finish-to-start: interlock testing cannot start until loop checks are complete, and water commissioning of the CIL cannot start until the water systems are operational.
  4. Identify the critical path, the longest chain of linked activities. In the example it runs through energisation, control system checks, loop checks, interlock testing, water commissioning, CIL and elution to first gold, and any delay on it delays first gold. Activities off the critical path have float and can slip slightly without delaying the end date.
  5. Set milestones, such as first ore and first gold pour, and the certificate dates that lead to them.
  6. Prepare a three-week look-ahead every week: the detailed plan for the following three weeks, checked against crews, vendors, spares and permits.

Scheduling software (Microsoft Project or Primavera P6) is standard on large projects, while a spreadsheet with a row per activity and a conditionally formatted bar per week is adequate for smaller ones. A single master schedule should be maintained and updated weekly from the commissioning register.

The punch list

A punch list (or punch log) records every defect or incomplete item found during walkdowns and testing. Each item is assigned a category that determines when it must be closed:

CategoryClose-out requirementExamples
ABefore the system is energised or run, because the item is a safety issue or prevents the system from workingMissing guard, incorrect motor rotation, missing pressure relief valve, unterminated cable
BBefore practical completion or handover; does not prevent commissioningMissing equipment labels, incomplete thermal insulation away from walkways, minor leaks at drain points
CAfter handover by agreement; minor or cosmeticPaint touch-ups, tidy-up of cable trays
IDSystemTagDescriptionCat.Raised by / dateAction byDueStatus
P-041233103310-PP-001Coupling guard not fittedACommissioning, 4 MarMechanical contractor6 MarClosed 5 Mar
P-041333103310-FIT-001Flowmeter cable gland not sealedBElectrical, 4 MarElectrical contractor20 MarOpen
P-04143310PlatformPaint damage on handrailCOwner, 5 MarPainting contractorAfter handoverOpen

Open items should be tracked by category every week. A burn-down chart shows whether the punch list will be cleared in time:

Open punch list items by categoryCategory A items fall from 120 to zero by week 7; category B rises to 420 in week 3 as walkdowns find more, then falls to 60 by week 10; category C rises to 230 then falls slowly to 150.010020030040012345678910WeekOpen itemsCategory ACategory BCategory CCategory A: 1 → 120Category A: 2 → 95Category A: 3 → 70Category A: 4 → 42Category A: 5 → 20Category A: 6 → 6Category A: 7 → 0Category A: 8 → 0Category A: 9 → 0Category A: 10 → 0A: zero by week 7Category B: 1 → 380Category B: 2 → 400Category B: 3 → 420Category B: 4 → 390Category B: 5 → 350Category B: 6 → 300Category B: 7 → 240Category B: 8 → 170Category B: 9 → 110Category B: 10 → 60BCategory C: 1 → 150Category C: 2 → 170Category C: 3 → 200Category C: 4 → 220Category C: 5 → 230Category C: 6 → 225Category C: 7 → 210Category C: 8 → 190Category C: 9 → 170Category C: 10 → 150C
A punch list burn-down. The early rise is normal: walkdowns find items faster than crews close them. What matters is that A items reach zero before the systems they affect are energised or run. Illustrative figures.
required closure rate=open itemsweeks remaining

where

open items
open punch list items of a category that must close by the milestone
weeks remaining
weeks until the milestone, such as ready for ore or practical completion

Example: 420 category B items are open six weeks before practical completion, so crews must close 420 ÷ 6 = 70 items per week. If they are closing 45, the date will be missed unless more crews are added or the list is triaged.

Equipment checklists and test sheets

Every equipment type has a pre-commissioning checklist and a commissioning test sheet, signed by the person who performed the check and witnessed by the commissioning engineer. Inspection and test plans (ITPs) from construction feed into them. A sample for a slurry pump:

#CheckPre-commissioning (dry)Water commissioning
1Isolations, permits and lock-out in place for the work✓✓
2Pump and motor alignment record, holding-down bolts torqued✓
3Gland seal water supply connected; pressure and flow set to vendor value✓✓
4Motor rotation checked uncoupled (bump test)✓
5Guards fitted; emergency stop and pull-wire tested✓
6Suction and discharge valves stroked; position feedback correct in the control system✓
7Variable speed drive parameters set and tested✓
8Run on water: flow, discharge pressure, motor current, vibration and temperatures recorded against vendor curve✓
9Interlocks tested live: low sump level trip, low seal water trip, downstream trips✓
10No leaks at flanges, gland and hoses✓

Similar sheets cover conveyors (belt tracking, pull-wires, belt rip and speed switches, guards), mills (lubrication systems, inching drive, liner bolt torque, brakes), agitated tanks (cleanliness before filling, level instruments, agitator rotation and run on water), screens and cyclones, valves (stroke time and fail-safe position), and instruments (loop checks and calibration). Interlocks are tested against the cause and effect matrix one line at a time, and each test is signed.

The RACI matrix

Commissioning brings together construction contractors, the commissioning team, the owner's operators, vendors and the project management team. A RACI matrix states who is Responsible for performing each activity, who is Accountable (one party only), who must be Consulted and who must be Informed:

ActivityConstruction contractorCommissioning teamOwner's operationsVendorsProject manager
Mechanical completion and punch walkdownsRCCIA
Pre-commissioning checksCR, ACCI
Vendor equipment start-upIACRI
Water commissioningCARCI
Ore commissioningIARCI
Ramp-upICR, ACI
Performance testCRRCA
Handover documentationRRCRA

The matrix should be adapted to the contract. Most commissioning disputes can be traced to a missing or ambiguous line in this table.

Operational readiness

A plant can be mechanically complete and still fail at start-up because the organisation is not ready. Readiness should be reviewed formally before water commissioning and again before ore:

AreaReady when
PeopleOperators and maintainers recruited, trained on the plant's own procedures and assessed as competent; rosters cover start-up around the clock
ProceduresStart-up, shutdown, emergency and isolation procedures written and tested on the plant during water commissioning
SafetyPermit to work and isolation systems in use; emergency response, first aid and cyanide response in place; hazard studies closed out
ConsumablesReagents, grinding media, lime, cyanide, carbon, flocculant and fuel on site with storage commissioned
SparesCommissioning and first-year spares received, catalogued and in the store
Laboratory and samplingSamplers commissioned, laboratory running with standards and quality control, turnaround agreed
Metal accountingSampling points, weightometers and flowmeters calibrated; the metal accounting system set up to report from the first shift
MaintenanceEquipment loaded in the maintenance system with preventive tasks and lubrication schedules
Permits and complianceOperating licences, cyanide code requirements and environmental monitoring in place

Safety during commissioning

Commissioning is one of the highest-risk periods in a plant's life. Equipment is energised for the first time, construction crews are still working nearby, systems are partly complete, and personnel are working in a plant with which they are not yet familiar.

Systems under construction control and systems under commissioning control should be clearly identified, with tags or locks at the boundaries, and energised systems must be under the permit to work and isolation system from the moment of energisation. Construction and commissioning work in the same area should be planned and reviewed daily. Stored energy is present before the plant runs, in pressure tests, tensioned belts, hydraulic systems and elevated loads.

Cyanide, acids and caustic should be introduced only after the storage, dosing, detection, emergency showers and response arrangements have been tested and personnel trained. An interlock must never be bypassed without a documented, approved and time-limited override.

Water commissioning

Operating the plant on water identifies most mechanical, control and hydraulic problems before ore makes them expensive. Water commissioning is used to:

  • Run every pump, agitator and conveyor (conveyors empty) for long enough to check temperatures and vibration.
  • Prove level, flow and density control loops, and tune them approximately.
  • Test interlocks and trips under real conditions, including recovery from power failure.
  • Check flowmeters against tank level changes (by filling a tank of known volume and comparing), and calibrate weightometers with test weights or test chains.
  • Flush construction debris from lines and tanks, and clean screens and strainers afterwards.
  • Rehearse start-up and shutdown sequences with the operators who will run the plant.

Ore commissioning

  1. Start with known, softer ore at a reduced rate, often 50 to 70% of design, so that problems remain small and recoverable.
  2. Bring circuits on line in process order: crushing to stockpile, grinding and classification, leach and adsorption, then elution and the gold room.
  3. Introduce reagents at calculated doses (see reagent dosing) and check them with titrations and pump calibrations from the first hour.
  4. Sample and account from the first shift. Shift samples, the laboratory and metal accounting must be operating before ore arrives, because the first weeks are when losses and measurement errors are most likely and most difficult to reconstruct later.
  5. Hold a short daily meeting for the commissioning and operations teams, covering the previous day's performance, the day's plan, the main issues and their owners.

Initial gold-in-circuit inventory

A new gold plant must build up its gold in circuit before poured gold matches recovered gold. Solution in the tanks, carbon in the CIL train, eluate, electrowinning cells and the gold room all hold gold. In the example plant, at 300 t/h and 1.8 g/t, about 48 kg of gold is held in the circuit at steady state.

Gold recovered and gold poured in the first monthRecovered gold rises steadily at about 12 kg a day; poured gold lags by about 48 kg, the gold needed to fill the circuit.0100200300051015202530Day after first oreCumulative gold (kg)Gold recovered from oreGold pouredRecoveredPoured
Filling the circuit. A new plant must load its solution, carbon, elution and gold room inventory before poured gold matches recovered gold. In practice the gap is often larger and takes longer to close than this simple model. Illustrative figures.

In a first full month at nameplate (216,000 t at 1.8 g/t, 389 kg of gold fed, 92% true recovery), the plant recovers 358 kg but pours about 310 kg. Poured-only recovery would be 80%, not 92%. Without a gold-in-circuit estimate, the first month's report would understate recovery and trigger an unnecessary investigation. Measurement of gold in circuit is covered in gold reconciliation and gold in circuit.

Ramp-up performance

Ramp-up curves: throughput as % of nameplateIllustrative shapes: a fast ramp-up reaches nameplate within a few months; a slow one approaches it after a year; a flawed project levels off well below design.0255075100024681012Months after first oreThroughput (% of nameplate)nameplateFast ramp-upSlow ramp-upNever reaches design
Illustrative ramp-up shapes. McNulty (1998) grouped real ramp-ups into four series of this kind and linked the slow ones to untested technology, limited piloting, design shortcuts and fast-tracking.

Ramp-up performance is tracked daily and reported monthly with a small set of measures. Definitions vary between companies and should be agreed before start-up:

Availability=calendar hours−maintenance downtimecalendar hoursUtilisation=run hourscalendar hours% of nameplate=tonnes treatednameplate rate×calendar hours×100

where

maintenance downtime
planned plus unplanned hours when the plant could not run because of equipment (h)
run hours
hours the plant actually treated ore; also excludes standby, such as no feed or no power from the grid (h)
nameplate rate
design throughput (t/h)

Example, month 2: 720 calendar hours, 36 hours of planned maintenance, 96 hours of unplanned downtime and 24 hours of standby with no feed. Availability = (720 − 36 − 96) ÷ 720 = 81.7%. Run time is 564 h, so utilisation is 78.3%. At an average of 260 t/h while running, the plant treated 146,640 t, which is 68% of the 216,000 t nameplate month.

These figures are improved most quickly by addressing the largest causes of lost time first. A downtime Pareto chart, built from the downtime log, identifies them:

Unplanned downtime by cause, month 2Cyclone feed pump 28 h, conveyor tracking and spillage 22 h, instrument faults 15 h, CIL screen blockage 12 h, power trips 9 h, lime system blockage 6 h, other 4 h.Cyclone feed pumpCyclone feed pump: 28 h28 hConveyor tracking, spillageConveyor tracking, spillage: 22 h22 hInstrument faultsInstrument faults: 15 h15 hCIL screen blockageCIL screen blockage: 12 h12 hPower tripsPower trips: 9 h9 hLime system blockageLime system blockage: 6 h6 hOtherOther: 4 h4 hUnplanned downtime (h)
A downtime Pareto from the ramp-up example: two causes make up half of the 96 hours lost. Fix the top of the list first. Illustrative figures.

An issues register should be maintained alongside it, recording every problem, its root cause, its owner and its due date. The investigation method should be applied to recurring problems.

The performance test

The performance test (also called a guarantee or acceptance test) demonstrates that the plant meets the contract guarantees, usually throughput, product size and recovery, and sometimes reagent and power consumption, over a set period at defined ore conditions.

  1. Write the test procedure before start-up and agree it with all parties: duration, ore type and blend, operating limits, measurements, sampling, laboratory and calculation methods, and the procedure if the test is interrupted.
  2. Agree the measurement basis for each guarantee. Throughput can be expressed per calendar hour or per operating hour:
Qcalendar=tonnes in testtest hoursQoperating=tonnes in testhours running

where

Qcalendar
average rate over the whole test period, including stoppages (t/h)
Qoperating
average rate while the plant was running (t/h); the contract must say which one the guarantee uses
  1. Check the instruments before the test: weightometer calibration, flowmeters, density gauges and samplers.
  2. Run the test with independent witnesses and a single, controlled log of events.
  3. Calculate the results from a reconciled mass balance, not from single assays; see recovery formulas and mass balance reconciliation.
GuaranteeRequiredMeasured (72 h test)Result
Throughput, per calendar hour≥ 300 t/h21,770 t ÷ 72 h = 302 t/hPass
Grind P80≤ 106 µm104 µm (average of shift composites)Pass
Gold recovery at design head grade≥ 92.0%92.4% (reconciled balance)Pass

Had the throughput guarantee been per operating hour, the 2.5 hours of stoppages during the test would have given 21,770 ÷ 69.5 = 313 t/h. The difference is the reason the basis must be agreed before the test.

Handover and close-out

  • Signed certificates for every system and phase.
  • Completed checklists, test sheets, loop and interlock records, and vendor reports.
  • As-built drawings, updated P&IDs, control system backups and the final cause and effect matrix.
  • Operating and maintenance manuals, spares lists and the spares themselves.
  • Training records and competency assessments.
  • The remaining punch list (category C and any agreed B items) with owners and dates.
  • A lessons-learned review while the experience is recent.

Common pitfalls

Commissioning planning that starts too late is the most common failure; the system breakdown, register and procedures should be ready before construction finishes. Compressing water commissioning to recover schedule is a false economy, because the problems not found then reappear with ore in the plant. Vendor representatives booked late, or for too short a period, delay the critical path.

If sampling and the laboratory are not ready, the first weeks of metal accounting are guesswork. Unrealistic ramp-up targets push the plant past known problems instead of resolving them. Every issue on the issues register needs a single owner, and test sheets must be kept in the commissioning register rather than in personal files.

Glossary

Mechanical completion
The point when a system is built and tested to construction requirements and ready for pre-commissioning.
Pre-commissioning
Checks and tests without process fluids: energising, loop checks, rotation, no-load runs, interlock tests.
Water commissioning
Running systems on water to test equipment, controls and interlocks under realistic conditions.
Ore commissioning
Introducing ore and reagents and bringing the process on line; also called hot commissioning.
Ramp-up
The period from first ore until the plant reaches its design throughput and recovery.
Punch list
The list of defects and incomplete items, each with a category, owner and due date.
Critical path
The longest chain of linked activities in a schedule; delays on it delay the end date.
Float
How long an activity can slip without delaying the end date.
RACI matrix
A table showing who is Responsible, Accountable, Consulted and Informed for each activity.
Cause and effect matrix
The table of what each trip or alarm does in the control system; used to test interlocks.
Performance test
A formal test that proves the plant meets its contract guarantees.
Nameplate
The design throughput of the plant.

Frequently asked questions

What are the phases of plant commissioning?

Construction completion and mechanical completion, pre-commissioning (cold, without process fluids), water commissioning, ore (hot) commissioning, ramp-up, and the performance test and handover. Each phase ends with a signed certificate.

What is the difference between A, B and C punch list items?

Category A items must be closed before a system is energised or run, because they affect safety or operation. Category B items must be closed before practical completion or handover. Category C items are minor and can be closed after handover by agreement.

How is a commissioning Gantt chart prepared?

List the activities by system from the commissioning register, estimate durations, link them (mostly finish-to-start), identify the critical path, add milestones such as first ore and first gold, and update it weekly with a three-week look-ahead. Scheduling software or a spreadsheet are both suitable.

Why is recovery low in the first month of a new gold plant?

Gold must fill the circuit, in solution, on carbon and in the elution circuit and gold room, before poured gold matches recovered gold. Gold in circuit should be measured from the start so that true recovery can be reported.

How long does ramp-up take?

It depends on how proven the flowsheet is and how well the project was prepared. Proven, well-prepared plants can reach nameplate within months; projects with new technology, limited piloting or design shortcuts can take years or never reach design.

What should a performance test procedure include?

Duration, ore type, operating limits, the guarantees and the measurement and calculation method for each, sampling and laboratory methods, instrument checks, the handling of interruptions, and the parties who witness and sign off.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. McNulty, T. (1998). Developing innovative technology. Mining Engineering, 50(10), 50–55.
  2. Hatch. The ramp-up series: beyond the curves (2025). Link
  3. Project Management Institute (2021). A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK Guide), 7th edition. PMI.
  4. Applying the AMIRA P754 Code of Practice for Metal Accounting. AusIMM MetPlant 2008.

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.