Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

Settling velocity: Stokes' law, Newton's law and hindered settling in slurries

Calculating particle settling velocity with Stokes' law, checking the Reynolds number, applying Newton's law to coarse particles, and correcting for hindered settling.

· 4 minute read · By

Particle settling velocity depends on particle size and density: a gold particle settles much faster than a quartz particle of the same size, and a coarse particle faster than a fine one of the same mineral. Settling behaviour underlies almost every classification and dewatering process, including cyclones, classifiers, thickeners, settling ponds and gravity separators.

For fine particles a simple relationship, Stokes' law, applies. Coarser particles, and particles in concentrated slurries, require corrections. This article sets out the settling equations and the checks that determine which one applies. The settling velocity calculator performs the arithmetic, including the Reynolds number check and the hindered settling correction.

Stokes' law

v=gd2(ρs−ρf)18μ

where

v
terminal settling velocity (m/s); valid for small particles in slow, smooth flow
d
particle diameter (m)
ρs, ρf
particle and fluid densities (kg/m³)
μ
fluid viscosity (Pa·s; 0.001 for water at 20 °C)

Worked example: a 75 µm quartz-like particle (density 2.7 t/m³) in water at about 20 °C (viscosity 1.0 mPa·s) settles at 9.81 × (75 × 10−6)² × 1,700 ÷ (18 × 0.001) = 0.0052 m/s, or 5.2 mm/s, about 19 m/h.

Stokes settling velocity in water at 20 °CSettling velocity rises with the square of size: at 20 micrometres quartz settles at 0.36 millimetres per second and pyrite at 0.87; at 60 micrometres quartz settles at 3.2 and pyrite at 7.8.02468102030405060Particle diameter (µm)Settling velocity (mm/s)Quartz, SG 2.65Pyrite, SG 5.0QuartzPyrite
Doubling the particle size makes it settle four times faster. A dense pyrite particle settles like a quartz particle about 1.6 times its size, which is why cyclones over-grind heavy minerals.

Reynolds number check

Re=ρfvdμNewton:v=3gd(ρs−ρf)ρf

where

Re
particle Reynolds number; Stokes’ law holds when it is small, roughly below 0.2 to 1
v, d
settling velocity (m/s) and particle diameter (m)
ρs, ρf
particle and fluid densities (kg/m³)
μ
fluid viscosity (Pa·s)
Newton:
the velocity of coarse particles in fully turbulent settling, as given in Wills’ Mineral Processing Technology

For the example particle, Re = 1,000 × 0.0052 × 75 × 10−6 ÷ 0.001 = 0.39. This is close to the limit of the Stokes range, so the true velocity is slightly lower than Stokes' law predicts. Above a Reynolds number of about 1, a drag correlation for the intermediate regime should be used, and for coarse particles in fully turbulent settling Newton's law applies. A 1 mm quartz particle settles at roughly 0.22 m/s by Newton's law, whereas Stokes' law would give about 0.9 m/s, four times too fast.

Hindered settling in slurries

vh=v×(1−φ)n

where

vh
hindered settling velocity in a suspension (m/s)
φ
volume fraction of solids
n
Richardson–Zaki exponent, 4.65 for slow (laminar) settling
How crowding slows settlingWith 10% solids by volume a particle settles at 61% of its free velocity; at 20% solids, 35%; at 30% solids, 19%; and at 40% solids, 9%.0.000.250.500.751.00010203040Solids by volume (%)Hindered ÷ free settling velocity(1 − φ)^4.65
Richardson–Zaki with n = 4.65. In thickener feeds and cyclone underflows, particles settle far slower than Stokes' law alone predicts.

Worked example: at 10% solids by volume, the example particle settles at 5.2 × 0.613 = 3.2 mm/s. At 30% solids by volume, roughly 54% solids by mass for an SG 2.7 ore, it would settle at less than a fifth of its free velocity. For this reason thickener feed is diluted in the feedwell and flocculated: flocs behave as much larger particles and settle fast enough for the thickener to be of practical size.

Implications for plant operation

Cyclone separation depends on settling velocity, so a dense mineral reports to the underflow at a finer size than the light gangue. Pyrite and gold are over-ground as a result; see hydrocyclone partition curves. In thickeners and clarifiers, the rise rate must remain below the settling rate of the finest particles that are to be retained; see thickener operation.

Water viscosity falls as temperature rises, so particles settle faster in summer than in winter, and settling tests should record the water temperature. Particle shape also matters: flat or irregular particles settle more slowly than spheres of the same volume, which is significant for micas and for flattened gold.

Glossary

Terminal settling velocity
The steady speed a particle reaches when drag balances its weight in the fluid.
Stokes' law
The settling velocity of a small sphere in slow, smooth (laminar) flow.
Reynolds number
A ratio showing whether flow around a particle is smooth or turbulent.
Newton's law
The settling velocity of a coarse particle in turbulent flow.
Hindered settling
Slower settling caused by neighbouring particles in a concentrated slurry.
Richardson–Zaki equation
A correction for hindered settling based on the solids volume fraction.
Viscosity
A fluid's resistance to flow; water is about 1 mPa·s at 20 °C.
Flocculation
Binding fine particles into larger flocs that settle faster.

Frequently asked questions

When does Stokes' law apply?

For small particles settling slowly, where the particle Reynolds number is below roughly 0.2 to 1. In water this usually means particles finer than about 50 to 100 µm, depending on density.

Why are gold and pyrite over-ground?

They settle faster than gangue of the same size, so cyclones return them to the mill in the underflow until they are finer than the surrounding gangue.

What is hindered settling?

The reduction in settling velocity in a concentrated slurry, because particles interfere with one another and the displaced liquid flows upward. At 20% solids by volume, particles settle at about a third of their free velocity.

Does temperature affect settling?

Yes. Warmer water is less viscous, so particles settle faster. The water temperature should be recorded in settling tests.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. Wills, B.A. and Finch, J.A. (2016). Wills' Mineral Processing Technology, 8th edition. Butterworth-Heinemann. Chapter 9, Classification.
  2. Richardson, J.F. and Zaki, W.N. (1954). Sedimentation and fluidisation: Part I. Transactions of the Institution of Chemical Engineers, 32, 35–53.

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.