Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

Cyanide speciation: free, WAD and total cyanide, HCN and pH, and the 50 mg/L WAD limit

Free, WAD and total cyanide: what each form includes, how it is measured, how pH determines the HCN fraction, and why WAD is used for tailings limits.

· 4 minute read · By

Cyanide in a gold plant is present in several forms. Free cyanide is available to dissolve gold and is the most toxic form. Some cyanide is bound in complexes with copper, zinc and other metals dissolved from the ore; some of these complexes dissociate readily and release their cyanide, while others, notably the iron complexes, are very stable. Laboratories therefore report cyanide in three main ways: free, weak acid dissociable (WAD) and total. Free cyanide governs the leach, WAD cyanide is the best guide to toxicity and is used for environmental limits, and total cyanide includes forms that are considerably less toxic.

This article describes the forms of cyanide, how each is measured, and how pH determines the proportion present as hydrogen cyanide. Plant titration for free cyanide is covered in free cyanide titration with silver nitrate, and destruction of cyanide in tailings in cyanide destruction.

Forms of cyanide and their measurement

free⊂WAD⊂total

where

free
HCN plus CN⁻
WAD
free cyanide plus cyanide in weak and moderately strong metal complexes, such as those of zinc, cadmium, copper, nickel and silver
total
WAD plus strong complexes, such as those of iron, cobalt and gold
FormIncludesTypical methods
FreeHCN and CN⁻Silver nitrate titration (plant control; it also picks up some weak copper complexes); flow injection with gas diffusion, such as ASTM D7237
WADFree cyanide plus complexes of zinc, cadmium, copper, nickel and silverDistillation at weakly acidic pH (APHA Standard Methods 4500-CN I); ligand exchange flow injection, such as ASTM D6888; picric acid methods
TotalWAD plus strong complexes of iron, cobalt and goldStrong-acid distillation, then measurement of the released cyanide (APHA 4500-CN C and finish)
Related speciesThiocyanate (SCN⁻) and cyanate (CNO⁻)Measured separately; not included in the cyanide results above
One tailings sample, three cyanide resultsFree cyanide 120 mg/L, WAD cyanide 180 mg/L and total cyanide 260 mg/L.Free cyanideFree cyanide: 120120WAD cyanideWAD cyanide: 180180Total cyanideTotal cyanide: 260260Cyanide as CN (mg/L)
Each result includes the one before it: WAD includes free cyanide, and total includes WAD. The differences are cyanide held in metal complexes. Illustrative figures.

Worked example: a tailings sample reports 120 mg/L free, 180 mg/L WAD and 260 mg/L total cyanide. The 60 mg/L between free and WAD is held in weak and moderately strong complexes, mostly of copper and zinc in many ores, and the 80 mg/L between WAD and total in strong complexes, mostly of iron. A set of results in which WAD is below free, or total below WAD, indicates a sampling, preservation or analytical problem.

Effect of pH on hydrogen cyanide

% as HCN=1001+10pH−pKapKa≈9.2 at 25 °C

where

% as HCN
share of the free cyanide present as hydrogen cyanide; the rest is the cyanide ion, CN⁻
pKa
acid dissociation constant of HCN as −log₁₀; about 9.2 at 25 °C, varying with temperature and salinity
Share of free cyanide present as HCN against pHAt pH 8 about 94% of free cyanide is HCN, at pH 9.2 about half, at pH 10.2 about 9% and at pH 11 under 2%.0255075100789101112pHFree cyanide present as HCN (%)pKa ≈ 9.2typical leach pHHCN
Below pH 9.2 most free cyanide is HCN, which is volatile and toxic as a gas. Leach circuits run at high pH to keep cyanide as CN⁻ and prevent HCN loss.

Worked example: at pH 10.2, the proportion of free cyanide present as HCN is 100 ÷ (1 + 101.0) = 9%. If the tailings pond falls to pH 8.5, the proportion rises to 100 ÷ (1 + 10−0.7) = 84%. HCN is volatile, so low pH results in faster loss of cyanide to air and a greater risk of gas exposure around tanks and launders. For this reason leach circuits are operated at high pH with lime, and HCN gas monitors are installed where solutions are handled.

Sampling and preservation

Cyanide results change after sampling, as HCN escapes, sulphides react with cyanide and light decomposes some complexes. Samples for WAD and total cyanide are usually filtered, raised to high pH with sodium hydroxide, kept cool and dark, and analysed promptly. The laboratory's preservation instructions should be followed, including any treatment required for sulphide or oxidants.

Environmental limits

The International Cyanide Management Code uses WAD cyanide for its wildlife protection limit of 50 mg/L in open waters at mine sites, such as tailings storage facilities, unless a site-specific alternative is justified. Limits for discharge to the environment are set by the regulator and are much lower. Free cyanide is the most toxic form, but WAD is used because the weaker complexes readily release free cyanide in the environment.

Glossary

Free cyanide
Hydrogen cyanide (HCN) plus the cyanide ion (CN⁻).
WAD cyanide
Weak acid dissociable cyanide: free cyanide plus cyanide released from weak and moderately strong metal complexes at mildly acidic pH.
Total cyanide
All cyanide, including strong iron, cobalt and gold complexes, released by strong-acid distillation.
Metal-cyanide complex
A dissolved compound of a metal ion with several cyanide ions, such as copper or iron cyanide.
pKa
The pH at which an acid is half dissociated; about 9.2 for HCN.
Thiocyanate
SCN⁻, formed when cyanide reacts with sulphur species; measured separately.
Cyanate
CNO⁻, the product of cyanide oxidation, much less toxic than cyanide.
International Cyanide Management Code
A voluntary industry code for the safe manufacture, transport and use of cyanide in gold mining.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between free and WAD cyanide?

Free cyanide is HCN plus CN⁻ only. WAD cyanide also includes cyanide held in weak and moderately strong metal complexes, such as copper and zinc cyanides, which release it readily.

Why is WAD cyanide used for tailings limits?

Because the weak complexes break down readily and release free cyanide, WAD is a better guide to the toxicity of a water than free cyanide alone, and it excludes the very stable iron complexes.

At what pH does HCN form?

HCN and CN⁻ are in equilibrium at all pH values. About half of the free cyanide is present as HCN at pH 9.2, and below that pH most of it is.

Can WAD cyanide be higher than total cyanide?

No. Total cyanide includes WAD. Results showing otherwise indicate a sampling, preservation or analytical problem.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. Mudder, T.I., Botz, M.M. and Smith, A. (2001). Chemistry and Treatment of Cyanidation Wastes, 2nd edition. Mining Journal Books.
  2. International Cyanide Management Institute (2021). Mining operations guidance (Standard of Practice 4.4 and related). Link
  3. APHA, AWWA and WEF. Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater, Method 4500-CN.
  4. ASTM D6888. Standard test method for available cyanides with ligand displacement and flow injection analysis.
  5. ASTM D7237. Standard test method for free cyanide with flow injection analysis using gas diffusion separation and amperometric detection.

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.