Spodumene, the principal lithium mineral in Western Australian hard-rock deposits, is denser than the associated gangue, so in a medium whose density lies between the two the spodumene sinks while the lighter minerals float. True heavy liquids are toxic and expensive at plant scale, so plants use a suspension of fine ferrosilicon powder, an iron-silicon alloy about 6.8 times as dense as water, in water. Ore and medium are pumped through a cyclone, where the separation takes place in seconds, and the magnetic ferrosilicon is recovered and reused.
This article covers the design calculations for a dense media separation (DMS) plant treating crushed spodumene ore. The testwork used to select cut densities is described in heavy liquid separation for spodumene, and the fine material that DMS cannot treat is directed to spodumene flotation.
Selecting cut densities
Spodumene has a specific gravity of about 3.1 to 3.2, compared with about 2.65 for quartz, about 2.55 to 2.76 for feldspars and about 2.8 to 2.9 for micas. Pure spodumene contains 8.0% Li₂O, so a 6% Li₂O concentrate is roughly three-quarters spodumene by mass. Composite particles of spodumene and gangue have intermediate densities and limit the sharpness of the separation.
A two-stage layout is common. The primary stage, at a low density, floats off the light quartz and feldspar so that the second stage treats less material. The secondary stage, at a higher density, sinks the spodumene-rich concentrate, and its floats are middlings that may be re-crushed and re-treated or sent to flotation. The actual densities are selected from heavy liquid washability curves for each size fraction, balancing concentrate grade against recovery.
Medium make-up
where
- medium density (t/m³, numerically the same as SG)
- volume fraction of ferrosilicon in the medium
- density of the ferrosilicon powder, about 6.8 t/m³
- density of water, 1.0 t/m³
| Medium density (t/m³) | Ferrosilicon by volume | Ferrosilicon per m³ of medium | Solids by mass |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.70 | 29.3% | 1,990 kg | 73.8% |
| 2.80 | 31.0% | 2,110 kg | 75.4% |
| 2.90 | 32.8% | 2,230 kg | 76.8% |
Worked example for 2.80: φ = (2.80 − 1.0) ÷ (6.8 − 1.0) = 0.310, so each cubic metre of medium contains 0.310 × 6,800 = 2,110 kg of ferrosilicon. Ferrosilicon grades differ in particle size and shape; finer, atomised grades give a more stable medium but cost more and are harder to recover. The medium must remain stable and must not settle in the cyclone, which limits how coarse the ferrosilicon can be at a given density.
The density at which particles actually separate in a cyclone is usually somewhat higher than the feed medium density, because the medium thickens towards the spigot. Plants therefore set the medium density from the measured separation density rather than the reverse.
Medium flow and cyclone feed head
where
- medium flow to the cyclone (m³/h)
- medium to ore ratio by volume
- ,
- ore feed rate (t/h) and ore density (t/m³)
- feed head at the cyclone inlet, in metres of medium
- head multiple: published guidelines give about 9 for coal and 12 to 20 for minerals
- cyclone diameter (m)
Worked example: 150 t/h of ore with a density of 2.75 t/m³ is 54.5 m³/h of solids. At a medium-to-ore ratio of 5:1 by volume, the cyclone requires 273 m³/h of medium, plus the ore, at its inlet. One published set of operating guidelines gives a feed head of about 9 cyclone diameters for coal and 12 to 20 for minerals, and notes that the air core becomes unstable below about 7 diameters. For a 510 mm cyclone at 12 diameters, the head is 6.1 m of medium, or 2.8 × 9.81 × 6.1 = 168 kPa at the inlet.
Cyclones can be fed by pump or by gravity from a constant-head tank. A constant-head tank maintains a steady inlet head by design, while pump feed is more compact but the head varies with the pump and the sump level. In either case the head must be held steady, because the separation density shifts when it changes.
The partition curve
Density tracers, coloured plastic cubes of known density, or sink-float analysis of the products give the fraction of each density class reporting to sinks, and a plot of these fractions is the partition curve.
where
- écart probable: how sharp the separation is; smaller is sharper
- ,
- densities at which 75% and 25% of the particles report to sinks, read from the partition curve
Worked example: 25% of particles report to sinks at 2.86 and 75% at 2.96. The separation density is 2.91 and the Ep is (2.96 − 2.86) ÷ 2 = 0.05. The Ep increases, indicating a less sharp separation, for fine particles, so it should be measured for each size fraction. A rising Ep over time points to worn cyclone components, an unstable medium or an unsteady feed head.
Medium recovery and losses
Every product passes over drain and rinse screens: the drain section returns medium directly, and sprays then wash the remaining medium from the particles. Magnetic separators recover the ferrosilicon from the dilute rinse water, and a densifier, often a small cyclone or spiral classifier, restores it to working density. A nuclear or other density gauge on the correct-medium line controls the addition of water or concentrated medium to hold the setpoint.
Ferrosilicon is lost on the products, in the magnetic separator tails and through abrasion to fines that no longer separate. Ferrosilicon consumption per tonne of ore is a significant cost and should be tracked weekly. Fines in the feed raise medium viscosity and contaminate the medium, so the feed is screened to remove them before DMS.
Glossary
- Dense media separation (DMS)
- Separation of particles by density in a heavy suspension of fine solids in water.
- Ferrosilicon (FeSi)
- An iron-silicon alloy powder, about 6.8 t/m³ and magnetic, used to make dense medium.
- Medium
- The ferrosilicon and water suspension in which particles separate.
- Cut density
- The density at which a particle has an equal chance of reporting to sinks or floats.
- Partition curve
- A plot of the fraction of each density class reporting to sinks.
- Ep (écart probable)
- Half the density difference between the 75% and 25% points of the partition curve; a measure of separation sharpness.
- Middlings
- Particles of intermediate density, often part spodumene and part gangue.
- Drain and rinse screen
- A screen that drains medium from a product and then rinses off the remainder for recovery.
Frequently asked questions
Why is DMS used for spodumene rather than jigs or spirals?
The density difference between spodumene and its gangue is too small for water-based gravity methods. A medium set between the two densities gives a much sharper separation.
What size range does DMS treat?
Crushed ore after removal of fines, often from several millimetres down to about half a millimetre. The exact range is set by testwork and plant design, and the fines are treated by flotation.
Why is the actual cut density higher than the medium density?
The medium thickens towards the cyclone spigot, so particles separate at a higher density than that of the medium entering the cyclone. The offset is measured with density tracers.
What does a high Ep indicate?
A less sharp separation, with more misplaced particles. Medium stability and density, feed head and cyclone wear components should be checked.
Discuss your plant with a metallurgist
Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.
Talk to a metallurgistReferences and further reading
- Wills, B.A. and Finch, J.A. (2016). Wills' Mineral Processing Technology, 8th edition. Butterworth-Heinemann. Chapter 11, Dense medium separation.
- 911 Metallurgist. Dense media separation (PDF). Link
- Practical operational aspects of dense medium cyclone separation (conference paper, reproduced on SlideShare). Link
Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.