Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

Screening efficiency: calculating the size separation achieved by a screen

Calculating screen efficiency from feed, oversize and undersize sizing, and the effect of near-size particles and worn panels on efficiency.

· 5 minute read · By

A vibrating screen separates ore by size as it travels across the deck. Particles smaller than the apertures pass through, and larger particles travel to the discharge end. In a crushing plant, screens return oversize to the crusher; in a grinding circuit, they protect the cyclones and the leach from trash and coarse rock.

No screen separates perfectly. Some fine particles are carried across on top of coarser material and leave with the oversize, and worn or torn apertures allow some coarse particles through. Screening efficiency quantifies the misplaced material and indicates whether a screen is overloaded, worn or incorrectly set up.

Screen efficiency is calculated from the same type of data as any metallurgical separation: a mass balance in which the "assay" is the percentage of material finer than the aperture. This article gives the formulas, a worked example and the practical causes of low efficiency.

Screen streamsFeed splits into oversize and undersize; each product contains some misplaced material.Feed Ff = 55% finesScreen6 mm apertureOversize Oo = 8% finesUndersize Uu = 97% fines
A sizing screen as a two-product separation. Fines left in the oversize and coarse particles in the undersize are both misplacement.

Mass split

The feed, oversize and undersize are sampled at the same time and each is sieved at the screen aperture size. The fraction finer than the aperture is f in the feed, o in the oversize and u in the undersize. The two-product formula, the same one used for metallurgical recovery, gives the split:

OF=f−uo−uUF=o−fo−u

where

F, O, U
mass flows of feed, oversize product and undersize product
f, o, u
fraction finer than the screen aperture in the feed, oversize and undersize

Worked example: a 6 mm screen in a crushing circuit, with a feed 55% finer than 6 mm, an oversize 8% finer and an undersize 97% finer. O/F = (0.55 − 0.97) ÷ (0.08 − 0.97) = 0.472, and U/F = 0.528. Of every 100 t of feed, 47.2 t leave as oversize and 52.8 t as undersize.

Screen efficiency

Eo=O(1−o)F(1−f)Eu=UuFfE=Eo×Eu=u(f−u)(o−f)(1−o)f(1−f)(o−u)2

where

Eo
recovery of coarse material to the oversize product
Eu
recovery of fine material to the undersize product
E
overall screen efficiency

For the example, the recovery of coarse material to the oversize is Eo = 0.472 × (1 − 0.08) ÷ (1 − 0.55) = 96.5%, the recovery of fines to the undersize is Eu = 0.528 × 0.97 ÷ 0.55 = 93.1%, and the overall efficiency is E = 0.965 × 0.931 = 89.9%.

Per 100 t of feed, 3.8 t of fines are carried to the oversize (47.2 × 0.08) and 1.6 t of coarse material reaches the undersize (52.8 × 0.03). The significance of each depends on the duty. In a crushing circuit, fines in the oversize recirculate and consume crusher capacity, while coarse material in the undersize reports to the mill feed and may matter more. On a safety screen ahead of a leach circuit, any coarse material in the undersize is a problem.

Sizing data are subject to the same sampling errors as assays. For important decisions the survey should be repeated and the data reconciled, as described in mass balance reconciliation.

Near-size particles

A particle passes only if it meets an aperture squarely. For a round particle and a square aperture, Gaudin's geometric analysis gives the probability of passage on each presentation:

p=(a−da+w)2

where

p
chance that a round particle passes on a single presentation to a square opening
a
aperture size (mm)
d
particle diameter (mm)
w
wire diameter (mm)
Chance of passing one opening against particle sizeParticles much smaller than the aperture pass easily; the chance falls to 14% at half the aperture size and 1.6% at 5 mm.02040600123456Particle diameter (mm)Chance of passing on one try (%)
Gaudin's probability of passage for a 6 mm square opening with 2 mm wire. Near-size particles need many tries to pass, which is why screens never reach 100% efficiency.

For a 6 mm aperture with 2 mm wire, a 1 mm particle has a 39% probability of passing on each presentation and will pass within a few presentations. A 5 mm particle has a probability of 1.6% and needs dozens of presentations; if the screen is short or the bed is deep, it leaves with the oversize. Ores with a high proportion of near-size material are difficult to screen efficiently with any equipment.

Causes of low screen efficiency

Overloading produces a deep bed that prevents fines from reaching the screen surface, and the fines content of the oversize rises with tonnage. Blinding and pegging have a similar effect: wet, sticky or clay-rich ore coats the apertures, near-size particles wedge in them, the open area falls and fines report to the oversize.

Worn or torn panels enlarge the apertures or create holes. Coarse material in the undersize is the characteristic sign, and the panels should be inspected and the oversize content of the undersize trended.

Poor feed distribution, with the feed concentrated on one side of the deck, uses only part of the screen area. On wet screens, insufficient spray water leaves fines attached to coarse particles. An incorrect stroke, speed or slope for the duty also reduces efficiency: excessive speed causes particles to bounce over the apertures, and insufficient speed allows the bed to deepen.

Glossary

Aperture
The size of the openings in the screen panel.
Oversize
Material that travels over the screen and leaves at the discharge end.
Undersize
Material that passes through the openings.
Near-size particle
A particle only slightly smaller than the aperture, which passes with difficulty.
Blinding
Openings coated or blocked by fine sticky material.
Pegging
Particles wedged in the openings.
Open area
The fraction of the screen surface that is opening rather than wire or panel.
Misplaced material
Fines in the oversize or coarse particles in the undersize.

Frequently asked questions

How is screen efficiency calculated?

Sieve the feed, oversize and undersize at the aperture size. Use the two-product formula to obtain the mass split, then calculate the recovery of fines to the undersize and of coarse material to the oversize. Overall efficiency is the product of the two.

What is a good screen efficiency?

It depends on the duty and the amount of near-size material. Efficiency should be tracked over time for each screen; a falling trend indicates overloading, blinding or wear.

Why is there oversize material in the screen undersize?

Usually because of worn or torn panels, damaged seals between panels, or panels with the wrong aperture. The deck should be inspected.

Why are fines reporting to the oversize?

Overloading, blinding, pegging, insufficient spray water or a short residence time on the deck. Tonnage and panel condition should be checked.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. Wills, B.A. and Finch, J.A. (2016). Wills' Mineral Processing Technology, 8th edition. Butterworth-Heinemann. Chapter 8, Industrial screening.
  2. Gaudin, A.M. (1939). Principles of Mineral Dressing. McGraw-Hill.

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.