The steel balls in a mill perform the grinding. Large balls carry more energy and can break coarse particles; small balls are more numerous, provide more surface and are more effective on fine particles. A mill requires balls large enough for the coarsest feed, and wear of those balls produces the smaller sizes.
Balls wear continuously as they grind. A ball mill typically consumes several tonnes of steel per day, which makes grinding media one of the largest consumable costs in a concentrator. Correct ball size selection and wear tracking are simple calculations with a significant effect on operating cost.
This article covers the three routine grinding media calculations: the make-up ball size, the mass of the ball charge, and the expected wear and daily make-up. The worked figures follow the 4.24 m mill sized in ball mill sizing.
Make-up ball size
where
- largest (make-up) ball diameter (mm)
- 80% passing size of the mill feed (µm)
- mill factor: 350 for wet overflow mills, 330 for wet grate-discharge mills, 335 for dry grate-discharge mills
- ore specific gravity
- Bond ball mill work index (kWh/t)
- mill speed as a fraction of critical speed
- mill diameter inside the liners (m); 3.281 converts metres to feet
Worked example: a wet overflow mill (K = 350) of 4.24 m inside diameter running at 75% of critical speed, treating an ore with SG 2.7, a work index of 14.3 kWh/t and a feed F80 of 8,000 µm. The feed term is (F80 ÷ K)0.5 = (8,000 ÷ 350)0.5 = 4.78. The second term is ρsWi ÷ (100 φc √(3.281D)) = 2.7 × 14.3 ÷ (100 × 0.75 × √13.9) = 0.138, with a cube root of 0.517. The ball size is dB = 25.4 × 4.78 × 0.517 = 63 mm.
The nearest standard size offered by the media supplier is selected and checked against similar operations. Different texts quote slightly different versions of the equation, so the result should be treated as a starting point.
The chart illustrates two relationships. Ball size follows the square root of feed size, so a coarser feed resulting from a crusher change requires larger balls. Smaller mills require slightly larger balls for the same feed, because the balls fall a shorter distance.
Balls that are too small cannot break the coarse feed, so coarse material accumulates in the mill and mill load and power draw drift. Balls that are too large waste energy on fine particles and accelerate liner wear. In SAG-ball circuits and regrind mills, ball size is often set by experience and testing rather than by this equation alone.
Ball charge mass
where
- mass of the ball charge (t)
- fraction of the mill volume filled by the ball bed, voids included
- ,
- inside diameter and effective length of the mill (m)
- bulk density of the ball bed (t/m³): steel density × (1 − voids), about 7.8 × 0.6 ≈ 4.7
For the 4.24 m × 6.36 m mill at 35% ball filling: 0.35 × (π × 4.24² ÷ 4) × 6.36 × 4.65 = 146 t of balls. The bulk density of a ball bed is about 4.6 to 4.7 t/m³, corresponding to steel at about 7.8 t/m³ with about 40% voids between the balls.
Ball filling is determined during shutdowns by measuring from the top liners to the charge surface; the charge filling calculator converts that measurement to a filling percentage.
Ball wear and daily make-up
Bond related ball wear in wet ball mills to the ore's abrasion index, measured in his abrasion test:
where
- Bond abrasion index of the ore (from the abrasion test)
- mill power drawn (kW)
For an abrasion index of 0.2, wear = 0.16 × (0.2 − 0.015)0.33 = 0.092 kg/kWh. At 1,818 kW this is 167 kg/h, or 4.0 t/d, and at 150 t/h it is 1.1 kg per tonne of ore.
Bond's correlation was developed for the steel balls of his time. Modern forged and cast high-chrome media often wear less, and the plant's own records are the best guide: every ball addition should be weighed, the power recorded, and the consumption in grams per kilowatt-hour calculated each month.
Make-up practice
Balls are added daily, or every shift, at the make-up size to replace the mass worn. Steady additions keep the charge level and the power draw steady. Power draw is the practical guide, since power falls as the charge wears, and holding power at the target holds the charge.
The charge level should be checked at every shutdown and the addition rate adjusted if it is drifting. Media consumption is best tracked in g/kWh rather than kg/t, because this separates media quality from changes in throughput and ore hardness.
Glossary
- Grinding media
- The steel balls (or rods) that grind ore in a mill.
- Make-up ball size
- The size of the new balls added to replace wear; usually the largest ball in the mill.
- Ball filling
- The fraction of the mill volume occupied by the ball bed, voids included.
- Bulk density
- Mass of the ball bed divided by the volume it occupies, voids included.
- Abrasion index, Ai
- Bond's laboratory measure of how abrasive an ore is to steel.
- Wear rate
- Steel lost from the balls per unit of energy (kg/kWh) or per tonne of ore (kg/t).
- Overflow mill
- A ball mill that discharges by slurry overflowing the discharge trunnion; K = 350 in the ball size equation.
- Grate-discharge mill
- A mill with a grate at the discharge end; K = 330 when wet.
Frequently asked questions
How is the correct ball size for a ball mill calculated?
With the Rowland and Kjos form of Bond's equation, using the feed F80, ore SG, work index, mill speed as a fraction of critical, mill diameter and the mill factor K. The result is rounded to a standard size and confirmed with the supplier.
What is the mass of the ball charge in a mill?
The mill volume multiplied by the ball filling and by the bulk density of the ball bed, which is about 4.6 to 4.7 t/m³ for steel balls.
What is a typical ball consumption?
It depends on ore abrasiveness and media quality. Bond's correlation gives kilograms per kilowatt-hour from the abrasion index, but plant records of media added per kilowatt-hour are the best measure.
Why does power draw fall between ball additions?
The balls wear and the charge mass falls, so the mill draws less power. Regular additions at the correct rate hold the charge and the power steady.
Discuss your plant with a metallurgist
Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.
Talk to a metallurgistReferences and further reading
- Rowland, C.A. and Kjos, D.M. (1980). Rod and ball mills. In Mular, A.L. and Bhappu, R.B. (eds), Mineral Processing Plant Design, 2nd edition. Society for Mining, Metallurgy and Exploration.
- Bond, F.C. (1964). Lab equipment and tests help predict metal consumption in crushing and grinding units. Engineering and Mining Journal, 165.
- Wills, B.A. and Finch, J.A. (2016). Wills' Mineral Processing Technology, 8th edition. Butterworth-Heinemann. Chapter 7, Grinding mills.
- University of Alaska Fairbanks. AMIT 135, Lesson 7: Ball mills and circuits. Link
Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.